How to Pick an ICP When You Have Zero Traction
If you have zero traction, your ICP is not a guess. It is a set of testable constraints. This guide helps you pick an ICP you can actually reach, message, and close.
TL;DR (the fastest path)
- Pick a buyer you can access (warm network, communities, list sources).
- Pick a painful problem with urgency (not a nice-to-have).
- Pick a simple offer you can explain in one sentence.
- Run 20 conversations before you write any long content.
The 3 ICP constraints that matter (early stage)
Reachability
Can you reliably get in front of this buyer within 7 days? If the answer is no, it is not your ICP yet.
Urgency
Is the problem expensive today? Not in theory. If the buyer can delay for 6 months, your outbound will feel impossible.
Winnability
Can you beat alternatives with a clear reason? If you cannot answer "why you" in one sentence, pick a narrower ICP.
Step-by-step: pick an ICP in 60 minutes
Step 1: list 3 reachable segments
Ignore the "best market" question. Start with reachability. Write down 3 segments you can access now.
- People you already know (previous coworkers, clients, peers)
- One community where your buyer hangs out
- One list source you can pull quickly (LinkedIn search, job boards, directories)
Step 2: pick one painful problem
Early traction is mostly problem selection. Choose a problem that has a clear "this week" trigger.
Step 3: write a one-sentence offer
The offer should be concrete and low-friction. If you need 5 minutes to explain it, it is too broad.
Step 4: run 20 conversations
Do not build in a vacuum. Run 20 short conversations (calls or DMs) and track 3 signals: urgency, budget, and clarity.
What to track (the only ICP scorecard you need)
| Signal | What good looks like | What bad looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Reach | You can contact 50 prospects in 1 hour | You spend days just finding names |
| Urgency | They have an active project or deadline | They say "maybe later" |
| Winnability | They agree your approach is different | They compare you to a generic alternative |
| Message clarity | They repeat your value back to you | You keep changing the pitch every call |
FAQ
What if I have multiple ideas?
Run short tests in parallel, but keep the work small. One segment, one problem, one offer, 20 conversations.
Is content a good ICP test?
Content is a slower test. Use it after you confirm the problem is urgent and the message is clear.
Want help picking your ICP?
Book a free consultation and we will pick an ICP and message you can test in the next 7 days.
Book a Call